There's a tendency in the fitness industry to look at someone's posture and immediately start trying to fix it. Or even more so, try to sell it. Side-by-side posture photos sold as proof of a miraculous cure to a problem we may have manufactured in the first place.
Rounded shoulders. Forward head. Anterior pelvic tilt. Whatever else we've decided looks "wrong."
But posture by itself doesn't tell us nearly as much as we like to pretend it does.
Your posture does not dictate function, although it may suggest it. And that distinction matters, because posture can still give us useful information without becoming the conclusion.
Somebody can stand or sit in a position that looks "wrong" and still move incredibly well. On the other hand, somebody can have what we would consider "good posture" and have very few movement options once we actually ask them to get moving.
That's the distinction that matters.
Our goal should be to outfunction bad posture.
Function and performance are better measuring sticks for success than a static posture photo.
Posture is really just one representation of how you're managing gravity at a specific moment in time. It can give us information. It can suggest there may be certain positions or ranges you bias more than others.
But the problem isn't necessarily the posture itself.
The problem is when you can't get out of it.
If your shoulders sit forward, can the rib cage still express variability?
Can the scapula upwardly and downwardly rotate?
Can the humerus rotate?
Can you function through meaningful ranges of the shoulder without pain or limitation?
If yes, is the static presentation really a problem?
If you live in that same posture and can't express any other options when you move, now we have something worth addressing.
This is where low-stimulus "corrective" work can be useful.
Not because a breathing drill or mobility exercise is magically going to "fix your posture," but because it might help you access positions you currently have trouble finding.
Putting this in context, we have to understand that training stimulus lies on a continuum.
Think about training modalities from least loadable, or even passive, to most loadable.
We might start with passive modalities like manual therapy or foam rolling. From there, move into stretching or breathing drills. Then into lower-load movement drill work: scap push-ups, serratus wall slides, thread-the-needle variations, hip airplanes, or other bodyweight drills that ask us to actively access and control those positions.
From there, we can move into increasingly loadable patterns where we actually reinforce those positions under meaningful stimulus.
The amount of stimulus needed to create a temporary change will depend on the individual. But if we want that change to last, we usually have to bridge the gap from remedial or low-load work into higher-level motor learning, capacity, and loadability.
Most importantly, once we can get access to these positions, we need to reinforce them with some meaningful degree of stimulus.
Build capacity there.
Build strength there.
Actually teach your body that those movement options are useful.
For years we've had things like upper-cross syndrome used as explanations for why someone's shoulders or neck hurt simply because of how they stand.
Instead of providing solutions that reinforce better movement options, we often rely on remedial drills that provide a temporary change without actually building the capacity to use those positions under greater demands.
You might feel better temporarily.
But if your movement options haven't actually changed, we haven't accomplished much.
Posture can be information.
It just shouldn't be the conclusion.
The goal isn't perfect posture.
The goal is having enough options to address current limitations, reduce future ones, and perform at the highest level your goals demand.
Whether that means feeling strong and moving well in day-to-day life, building a balanced physique, or performing at a high level in sport, function is still the measuring stick.
Want this applied to your own training? See Online Coaching.
Get the next article a week early. Subscribe to the Unbranded Performance newsletter.